Sample Counter Offer Letter for Insurance Settlement: Easy & Stress-Free

In this article, I will guide you step-by-step on how to write an effective counter-offer letter for your insurance settlement, and provide customizable templates to kickstart your letter-writing process.

Key Takeaways:

  • Understand the basics of an insurance settlement and the role of a counter-offer letter.
  • Learn step-by-step how to draft an effective counter-offer letter.
  • Discover tips for successful negotiation and achieving a favorable settlement.
  • Free Template: Utilize a ready-to-use template to kickstart your letter writing.

Understanding the Basics

Before diving into letter writing, it’s crucial to understand what a counter-offer letter is. When you receive a settlement offer from an insurance company that doesn’t meet your expectations or needs, a counter-offer letter is your chance to negotiate. It’s a formal way to state your case, backed by facts and figures, to get a better deal.

Step 1: Gather Evidence

Start by gathering all relevant documents and evidence. This includes medical bills, repair estimates, and any other documentation that supports your claim.

  • List of Essential Documents:
    • Medical reports and bills.
    • Repair estimates.
    • Photos of damage or injury.
    • Police reports, if applicable.

Step 2: Analyze the Initial Offer

Understand the initial offer thoroughly. Determine why it’s inadequate and how much more you need. This will be the foundation of your counterproposal.

Trending Now: Find Out Why!

Step 3: Drafting the Letter

Begin your letter with a polite and professional tone. Clearly state that you are writing in response to the settlement offer and include your claim number for reference.

  • Key Components of the Letter:
    • Introduction: State the purpose of the letter.
    • Facts: Outline the facts of your case.
    • Justification: Explain why the initial offer is insufficient.
    • Counter Offer: State your counter-offer amount.
    • Supporting Documents: Reference your attached documents.
    • Conclusion: Summarize your points and express willingness to negotiate.

Step 4: Justify Your Counter Offer

This is where you make your case. Use real-life examples and specifics from your situation to justify why you deserve a higher settlement. Explain

how the offered amount fails to cover all your expenses and losses. Be detailed and factual.

Example: “In the initial offer, the cost of physical therapy needed for my complete recovery was overlooked. As per the attached medical reports, an additional six weeks of therapy, amounting to $1,200, is essential.”

Step 5: Review and Edit

Review your letter for clarity and conciseness. Make sure it’s free of errors and presents your case strongly yet professionally. If possible, have someone else read it for an unbiased opinion.

Step 6: Send the Letter

Send the letter through a trackable method, such as certified mail or email with a read receipt. This ensures that you have proof of delivery.

Template for Counter Offer Letter

[Your Name]
[Your Address]
[City, State, Zip]

[Adjuster’s Name]
[Insurance Company Name]
[Company Address]
[City, State, Zip]

Re: Claim Number: [Your Claim Number]
Date of Loss: [Date of Incident]

Dear [Adjuster’s Name],

I am writing in response to the settlement offer dated [Date of Offer] for the above-mentioned claim. After thoroughly reviewing the offer and assessing my damages and losses, I find that the proposed amount does not adequately cover my expenses and the impact of the incident.

[Provide a brief overview of the incident and the inadequacy of the initial offer.]

Therefore, I am presenting a counter-offer of [Your Counter Offer Amount]. This amount is based on [Justify your amount with specific reasons, including calculations and reference to supporting documents].

I believe this amount more accurately reflects the fair and just compensation required to cover all my expenses and losses related to the incident.

Enclosed, please find the following documents to support my counter-offer:
[List of supporting documents]

I appreciate your attention to this matter and look forward to a prompt and fair resolution. I am open to discussing this matter further if needed.

Thank you for your consideration.


[Your Name]
[Your Contact Information]


Writing a counter-offer letter for an insurance settlement is about clearly communicating your needs and backing them up with solid evidence. Be factual, concise, and polite. Remember, negotiation is a process, and your counter-offer letter is a crucial part of that.

I hope this guide helps you in drafting a letter that not only conveys your position effectively but also leads to a successful negotiation.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

A professional and inviting office setting with a person sitting at a desk, writing a letter

Q: What Should I Include in a Counter Offer Letter for an Insurance Settlement?

Answer: In my counter offer letter, I made sure to clearly state the amount I was countering with and why. I included detailed explanations of my damages, relevant medical bills, and any lost wages. It’s crucial to be specific and attach any supporting documents.

Q: How Do I Determine a Fair Counter Offer Amount?

Answer: When I determined my counter offer amount, I calculated all my expenses and losses related to the incident. This included medical expenses, property damage, and any lost income. Then, I added an amount for pain and suffering. Researching similar cases helped me get a ballpark figure.

Q: Is It Necessary to Hire a Lawyer for Writing a Counter Offer Letter?

Answer: In my experience, it wasn’t necessary to hire a lawyer for writing the letter, but consulting one gave me confidence. A lawyer helped me understand my rights and the fair value of my claim. However, for straightforward cases, one might draft the letter independently.

Q: How Long Should I Wait for a Response to My Counter Offer?

Answer: After sending my counter offer, I waited about two weeks for a response. It’s reasonable to expect a reply within 10 to 30 days. If there’s no response, I found it effective to send a follow-up inquiry.

Q: Can I Negotiate Further if the Insurance’s Second Offer is Still Low?

Answer: Absolutely. In my case, I negotiated further. It’s a process of back-and-forth until a mutually agreeable settlement is reached. Each time, I justified my counter with clear reasons and evidence. Patience and persistence are key.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *